There are some problems with pacing
and plot
development in John Ford's SHE WORE A YELLOW RIBBON (mainly because its
storyline was patched together from two short stories), but it attains
classic status on the basis of action scenes that are thrilling and
suspenseful (and a few that are downright frustrating), breathtaking
panoramas of Ford's beloved Monument Valley, and a masterful and
heartfelt performance by John Wayne as Captain Nathan Brittles, one of
the actor's most ingratiating roles. It is Capt. Brittles's story
that holds the loose narrative together, as he prepares for retirement
and wards off Indian attacks during his last hours on the job.
Don't look for a plot in SHE WORE A YELLOW RIBBON, don't even look for
episodic structure. The film works best if you think of it as a
series of little Western vignettes: some thoughtful, some
action-packed, some even anticlimactic, all loads of fun. The
second (after FORT APACHE and preceding RIO GRANDE) in Ford's Calvary
Trilogy, it's also my favorite for the sheer quirkiness of it all.
- JL