This early Hitchcock talkie is a mostly
ponderous affair, redeemed by a gripping climactic scene set in a
circus and a surprise finale. As with most of Hitchcock's films
from the period, the best moments are visual, such as his use of the
subjective camera during the opening murder sequence. Other
moments -- such as the lengthy internal monologues by Herbert Marshall
as he stares into a mirror -- just don't cut it. Hitch was still
learning, even if he was an "A" student.
½ -
JL